The Future of Leadership: Who Could Replace Selwyn as Commissioner on Death in Paradise?
The Future of Leadership: Who Could Replace Selwyn as Commissioner on Death in Paradise?
Commissioner Selwyn Patterson has led Saint Marie’s police force with grace, wit, and strength. But as change looms, fans are asking: who’s next in line for leadership?
Why Selwyn Patterson’s Role Is Irreplaceable
Selwyn Patterson has been the backbone of Honoré Police Department since 2011.
Played by Don Warrington, Selwyn is calm under pressure, politically astute, and commands respect. Whether mentoring detectives or managing high-profile cases, he brings a rare blend of discipline and heart.
He’s more than a boss—he’s part of the show's soul. For long-time fans, imagining Death in Paradise without him feels almost impossible. But recent storylines and behind-the-scenes whispers suggest that transition may be near.
So, who has what it takes to step up?
Sterling Fox – The New Face of Leadership?
Who Is Sterling Fox?
Sterling Fox, played by Trieve Blackwood-Cambridge, made a dramatic entrance in Season 13. With a flashy style and bold attitude, he’s already making waves.
In his first scene, he dismissed Selwyn’s office as “cute,” signaling that he’s not afraid to shake things up. While little is known about his backstory, his confidence suggests a possible future in leadership.
Pros and Cons of Sterling Fox as Commissioner
Pros:
-
Fresh ideas: Could modernize outdated systems.
-
Strong presence: Commands attention in every scene.
-
Decisive: Not afraid to challenge norms.
Cons:
-
Brash demeanor: May alienate long-time staff.
-
Lack of tact: Undermining Selwyn might hurt credibility.
-
Unproven loyalty: Still new to the team dynamic.
Fan Reactions to Sterling Fox
Social media feedback is mixed:
“He’s got energy, but Selwyn’s calm wisdom is hard to beat.” – Reddit
“I like the new guy! He brings tension, and that’s good drama.” – Twitter, @DipFan
Some fans are intrigued by the shift. Others worry he lacks the emotional depth Selwyn offered.
Could Catherine Bordey Step Up as Commissioner?
Why Catherine Might Be a Good Fit
Catherine Bordey, portrayed by Élizabeth Bourgine, is one of the show’s original characters. As Mayor of Saint Marie, she knows the people, culture, and pulse of the island.
She’s smart, compassionate, and respected—qualities that make her a strong leadership candidate.
Pros and Cons of Catherine Bordey as Commissioner
Pros:
-
Deep community ties: Trusts and understands the locals.
-
Wise and fair: Already manages complex civic duties.
-
Seen it all: Has supported detectives since Season 1.
Cons:
-
No policing background: Could struggle with investigative leadership.
-
Might resist systemic change: Prefers stability over disruption.
Fan Speculation About Catherine
Many fans love the idea of a maternal figure leading the force.
“She’s a pillar of the island. Why not elevate her even more?” – Facebook Comment
“I’d love to see Catherine bring a new kind of leadership.” – Instagram, @DeathInParadiseFanUK
Other Potential Candidates for Commissioner
Returning Characters – A Nostalgic Option
-
Dwayne Myers (Danny John-Jules): A fan favorite with insider experience. His charisma could revitalize the team.
-
Camille Bordey (Sara Martins): Former DS with deep ties to the island and experience leading investigations.
These returns would generate fan buzz and continuity, but reintroducing them must fit the current narrative.
New Faces – A Bold Direction
The show could introduce a completely new character as Commissioner—someone from the mainland or overseas. This would offer:
-
A clean slate for leadership.
-
Opportunities to explore culture clashes or modernization themes.
Challenges Ahead for Any New Commissioner
No matter who replaces Selwyn, the role won’t be easy. Key leadership challenges include:
-
Earning team trust: Especially from long-serving officers like Marlon and Naomi.
-
Balancing tradition with innovation: Fans love the old-school charm; change must be respectful.
-
Protecting Saint Marie’s values: New leadership must fit the island’s tone—sunny, calm, and community-centered.
Who Should Lead Saint Marie Into the Future?
Here’s a quick breakdown of top candidates:
| Candidate | Strengths | Challenges |
|---|---|---|
| Sterling Fox | Modern, confident, assertive | Brash, lacks team rapport |
| Catherine Bordey | Wise, empathetic, community-driven | No policing background |
| Dwayne Myers | Loved by fans, experienced in local law | Long absence may create continuity gap |
| Camille Bordey | Skilled, emotionally intelligent | Would need a compelling reason to return |
| New Character | Opportunity for fresh start | Risk of alienating long-time fans |
Your Turn: Who Should Be the Next Commissioner?
Selwyn Patterson has been more than a leader—he’s the spirit of Saint Marie’s justice system. But should he step down, the next Commissioner must balance legacy and innovation.
🗳️ Vote Below!
Who should replace Commissioner Selwyn Patterson?
-
Sterling Fox
-
Catherine Bordey
-
Dwayne Myers
-
Camille Bordey
-
A new character
👇 Tell us in the comments: Who do you think is most fit to lead Saint Marie into its next chapter?
People Also Ask (FAQs)
-
Is Selwyn Patterson leaving Death in Paradise?
There are hints, but no official confirmation yet from BBC. -
Who is Sterling Fox in Death in Paradise?
A new character introduced in Season 13, portrayed by Trieve Blackwood-Cambridge. -
Has Catherine Bordey been a leader before?
Yes, she is the Mayor of Saint Marie and a long-standing community leader. -
Could Dwayne or Camille return?
It's possible, and fans have long hoped for their return. -
What makes a good Commissioner on Saint Marie?
Balance of experience, emotional intelligence, and respect for tradition.
