Why Did Commissioner Selwyn Patterson Leave Death in Paradise?

Death in Paradise fans were left emotional as the beloved BBC drama wrapped up its latest season with a shocking farewell. After years of guiding Saint Marie’s police force, Commissioner Selwyn Patterson (Don Warrington) made the unexpected decision to leave. But why did he go? And is this truly the end for one of the show’s most iconic characters? Let’s break it all down!

Selwyn Patterson’s Exit Shocks Fans

As the season finale unfolded, audiences were prepared for one major departure—that of DI Mervin Wilson (Don Gilet), who had planned to return to London. However, after getting caught up in a murder investigation, he chose to stay in Saint Marie.

Yet, just as viewers breathed a sigh of relief over Mervin’s fate, the real heartbreak came—Selwyn announced his departure from the island.

Why Did Selwyn Patterson Leave?

While celebrating with his team at Catherine’s Bar, Selwyn arrived in a taxi rather than joining the festivities. When Catherine Bordey (Élizabeth Bourgine) encouraged him to take a seat, he dropped the bombshell—he was leaving.

The previous episode saw Selwyn being offered his old job back, but he ultimately turned it down. When asked why, he responded:

"I don’t know, but it felt wrong to say yes. Too much has happened, and right now, I can’t see a way to get back to how things were."

It was clear that Selwyn had reached a turning point in his life—perhaps the weight of his long-standing career or personal struggles played a role in his decision.

A Goodbye… or Just an "Au Revoir"?

Before he left, Selwyn told Catherine to look after the team. She, in turn, made him promise that this wasn’t a permanent farewell but simply au revoir.

Selwyn’s final stop before leaving was to see DI Mervin Wilson, revealing to him that he had a long-lost brother. Could this mysterious revelation hint at a potential return for Selwyn in the future?

Will Selwyn Patterson Return?

Although Selwyn’s departure was emotional, Death in Paradise has a history of bringing back fan-favorite characters. Given his status as a staple of the show, there’s always a chance he could return in a future season.

For now, fans can only hope that Don Warrington’s departure is temporary. After all, the island of Saint Marie just wouldn’t feel the same without its legendary commissioner!

FAQs

1. Why did Don Warrington leave Death in Paradise?

The BBC has not officially confirmed the real-life reason behind Don Warrington’s departure. It’s possible that the actor wanted to explore other projects, or that the storyline naturally led to Selwyn’s exit.

2. Will Selwyn Patterson come back?

It’s uncertain, but his farewell scene left the door open for a potential return. His promise to Catherine suggests that his departure might not be permanent.

3. Who is replacing Selwyn as commissioner?

The BBC has not yet announced a replacement, but future episodes may introduce a new character to take over the role.

4. Where can I watch Death in Paradise?

All episodes are available to stream on BBC iPlayer.