Why Death in Paradise’s Gary Carr Left – Fans Still Love Fidel Best

 Why Death in Paradise’s Gary Carr Left – Fans Still Love Fidel Best

The latest season of Death in Paradise has introduced Detective Mervin Wilson, played by Don Gilet, bringing fresh energy to the BBC One series. But while new faces arrive, longtime fans can’t help but reminisce about some of their favorite characters from the past. And topping that list? None other than Fidel Best, portrayed by the talented Gary Carr.

Fidel Best: A Fan-Favorite from the Start

From the very first episode, Fidel Best was a core part of the Honoré Police force. As the youngest detective on the team, he constantly worked to prove himself. His journey was one of growth, determination, and family devotion. When his wife Juliette gave birth to their daughter Rosie, Fidel became even more motivated to excel in his career, striving to provide the best life for his family.

Throughout his time on the show, he held deep respect for his superiors and was determined to climb the ranks. His ambition eventually led him to take his Sergeant exams—a challenge he passed with flying colors.

Gary Carr’s Departure: Why Did He Leave?

Fidel’s promotion meant more responsibilities at the Saint Marie station, but it also sparked his desire to explore new opportunities beyond the island. In Season 4, his character made a life-changing decision: he accepted a position with the police force on the neighboring island of St. Lucia.

But why did Gary Carr, the actor behind Fidel, decide to leave? While Carr himself never gave a detailed explanation, his co-star Kris Marshall shared insights into the decision. Speaking to Digital Spy, Marshall hinted that Carr simply wanted to pursue new ventures:

“It wasn’t a shock. I understand where he is coming from. I was just the same when I was younger. He wants to move on.”

And move on he did. Since leaving Death in Paradise, Gary Carr has taken on impressive roles, including parts in Bluestone 42, HBO’s The Deuce, and the Hollywood film 21 Bridges.

Fidel’s Legacy: Fans Still Want Him Back

Despite his exit years ago, Fidel Best remains a beloved character in the Death in Paradise fandom. Reddit threads continue to buzz with discussions about his impact on the series. In one particularly lively conversation, user Snowlock27 shared their appreciation:

“He was one of my favorites.”

Another fan, Steups13, even suggested an epic return:

“I would like Fidel to come back as Detective Inspector.”

With Death in Paradise known for bringing back familiar faces (like Camille and Dwayne in past seasons), could we see Fidel Best return in a major storyline? It’s something fans would absolutely love!

Final Thoughts: Could We See Gary Carr Back in Saint Marie?

Death in Paradise has always had a special way of keeping past characters alive in the hearts of fans. Fidel Best’s departure left a gap, but his legacy remains strong. With so many devoted viewers hoping for a comeback, who knows? Maybe one day, Gary Carr will grace our screens again as a more seasoned, wiser Detective Inspector Fidel Best.

What do you think? Would you love to see Fidel back on the island? Let us know in the comments below!

FAQ Section

Why did Gary Carr leave Death in Paradise?
Gary Carr never gave an official reason, but co-star Kris Marshall suggested he simply wanted to move on and explore new acting opportunities.

Where is Gary Carr now?
Since leaving the show, Gary Carr has appeared in Bluestone 42, The Deuce, and 21 Bridges.

Could Fidel Best return to Death in Paradise?
Fans are eager to see him come back, possibly as a Detective Inspector. Given the show’s history of bringing back old characters, it’s not impossible!

Who replaced Fidel Best on the show?
After Fidel’s departure, Officer JP Hooper (Tobi Bakare) stepped in to fill his shoes.