Hallmark Star Calls It a ‘Miracle’ That Jack Wagner Landed ‘When Calls the Heart’ Role

It’s hard to believe, but even a seasoned actor like Jack Wagner faced doubts about his casting in When Calls the Heart! According to his former Melrose Place co-star and Hallmark Channel alum Daphne Zuniga, Wagner’s leap from scandalous soap opera plots to the wholesome world of Hope Valley was nothing short of a "miracle."

Zuniga hilariously reflected on Wagner’s career transition during the March 22, 2025, episode of her Still This Place podcast, co-hosted with fellow Melrose Place veterans Laura Leighton and Courtney Thorne-Smith, both of whom have appeared in Hallmark films.

Jack Wagner’s Surprising Journey from ‘Melrose Place’ to ‘When Calls the Heart’

“Basically, Jack Wagner’s career has swung like a pendulum,” Zuniga joked. “He’s gone from the darkest of dark soap drama to one of the most wholesome shows on TV.”

Wagner, now 65, chuckled as his co-stars playfully teased him about the contrast between his reputation as a bad boy on Melrose Place and his buttoned-up character, Bill Avery, on When Calls the Heart. The beloved Hallmark series was recently renewed for an impressive 13th season, proving its enduring popularity.

Did the Producers Even Know Who Jack Wagner Was?

Thorne-Smith, who starred in Hallmark’s Emma Fielding Mysteries from 2017 to 2019, admitted that before Wagner joined the podcast, she had taken a deep dive into the When Calls the Heart fandom.

“I went down a total rabbit hole,” she confessed, marveling at the passionate fanbase, known as the Hearties. “They keep this community alive all year round, and I think it’s extraordinary. People are really looking for connection, and what a sweet way to find it.”

Wagner agreed, adding, “That’s such a great point, Courtney. I think this show resonates because of where we are culturally and politically. People want something that feels safe. There’s no violence, no profanity, no nudity—but we still get to fire a gun now and then!”

Zuniga then quipped, “Honestly, Jack, it’s kind of a miracle you were cast in this show if you really think about it. Your agents must be geniuses!”

Thorne-Smith, laughing, chimed in, “Did they even know who you were before they hired you?” Leighton joined the fun, teasing, “They must not have done much research!”

Despite the playful ribbing, Wagner has become a fan favorite on When Calls the Heart. His character, Bill Avery, has undergone significant growth over the years, evolving from a mysterious outsider to one of the most beloved figures in Hope Valley.

With When Calls the Heart continuing to captivate audiences, Wagner’s unexpected journey from soap opera scandal to wholesome Hallmark hero proves that in Hollywood, anything is possible.

Conclusion

Jack Wagner’s transition from Melrose Place heartthrob to When Calls the Heart staple is a testament to his versatility as an actor. Despite his past roles in drama-filled soap operas, he has seamlessly adapted to the warm, family-friendly atmosphere of Hope Valley. Fans can look forward to more of his heartfelt performances as the show moves into its 13th season!

FAQ

1. How long has Jack Wagner been on When Calls the Heart?
Jack Wagner joined the cast in 2014 and has been a key part of the show for over a decade.

2. What other Hallmark movies has Jack Wagner starred in?
Wagner has appeared in Hallmark's The Wedding March movie series, among other projects.

3. What is When Calls the Heart about?
The series follows the lives of people in the small frontier town of Hope Valley, focusing on love, friendship, and community.

4. Why is When Calls the Heart so popular?
The show offers heartwarming, family-friendly storytelling with strong themes of hope, faith, and perseverance, making it a favorite among fans.