Death in Paradise Creator Reveals Why New Crime Drama Is a Joy to Write

Why Death in Paradise’s Creator Prefers Writing His New Mystery Drama

Death in Paradise mastermind Robert Thorogood has opened up about why his latest crime series is a breath of fresh air compared to the long-running BBC hit. While fans of the sun-soaked detective show remain devoted, Thorogood admits that stepping into a new storytelling format has been an exhilarating change.

During a recent Q&A session for the highly anticipated second season of The Marlow Murder Club, the showrunner candidly discussed why he finds his latest project "more joyous to write" than Death in Paradise.

Breaking Free from the Episodic Formula

Thorogood explained that one of the biggest differences between the two shows lies in their storytelling structures. Death in Paradise follows a traditional episodic format, with a brand-new mystery wrapped up neatly within each episode. While this formula has made the show a global hit, the writer revealed that it can sometimes feel restrictive.

"With Death in Paradise, it’s all about keeping the plot moving constantly. Every moment must drive the mystery forward," he told reporters, as per Radio Times. "But with The Marlow Murder Club, I have the freedom to let the story breathe."

Unlike Death in Paradise, which is packed with fast-paced detective work and rapid resolutions, The Marlow Murder Club unfolds its mysteries over a two-episode arc. This approach, Thorogood says, allows for deeper character development and a richer, more immersive experience.

More Time for Character Development and Relationships

One of the biggest benefits of the new format, according to Thorogood, is the ability to focus on the heart of the story—the characters.

"What I loved most about Death in Paradise were the little character moments, the conversations between detectives, the small but meaningful interactions that built relationships. But when you only have 45 minutes to tell an entire story, you don't get much room for that," he explained.

Thankfully, UKTV gave Thorogood the creative freedom he needed to expand the storytelling approach for The Marlow Murder Club. Initially, the network wanted a case-of-the-week structure similar to Death in Paradise. However, the showrunner pitched an alternative: letting the mysteries unfold over two episodes to provide ample time for both plot and character dynamics.

"UKTV didn’t have a model for this approach, but they believed in the idea so much that they created one for us," Thorogood revealed. "Without them, we wouldn’t have had the space to make these stories as rich and engaging as they are."

What to Expect from The Marlow Murder Club Season 2

Led by the phenomenal Jo Martin, The Marlow Murder Club follows three amateur sleuths—Suzie Harris (Jo Martin), Judith Potts (Samantha Bond), and Becks Starling (Cara Horgan)—as they unravel local mysteries in their quaint English town. The second season promises to deliver even more compelling whodunits, with three brand-new cases spread across its six-episode run.

Fans won’t have to wait long to dive back into the intrigue, as The Marlow Murder Club returns to U&Drama and U on Wednesday, March 19th, at 8 PM. For those who missed the first season, it’s currently available for streaming on U.

Final Thoughts: Why This Change Matters

For fans of Death in Paradise, this shift in format might come as a surprise, but Thorogood’s enthusiasm suggests that The Marlow Murder Club could offer an even richer experience. By allowing the story to unfold over multiple episodes, viewers get a chance to connect more deeply with the characters and truly savor the mystery.

So, are you excited about The Marlow Murder Club’s return? Do you prefer self-contained mysteries like Death in Paradise, or do you enjoy a longer build-up? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!

FAQ Section

Q: When does The Marlow Murder Club Season 2 premiere?
A: The new season debuts on Wednesday, March 19th, at 8 PM on U&Drama and U.

Q: How is The Marlow Murder Club different from Death in Paradise?
A: Unlike Death in Paradise, which wraps up each case in a single episode, The Marlow Murder Club stretches its mysteries over two episodes, allowing for deeper storytelling and character development.

Q: Will Death in Paradise continue alongside The Marlow Murder Club?
A: Yes! Death in Paradise remains a BBC staple, while The Marlow Murder Club offers fans a fresh take on the crime genre.

Q: Where can I watch Season 1 of The Marlow Murder Club?
A: The first season is available for streaming on U.